Undergrad needs four years

The Ministry of Colleges and Universities has floated some ideas concerning post-secondary education reform.

Suggestions include a three-year bachelor’s degree, year-round class and allowing students to earn half of their credits online.

These are changes that need to be resisted in order to protect the integrity, depth and breadth of a four-year bachelor’s degree.

On Feb. 21, the provincial government’s Higher Education Quality Council published a report suggesting that Ontario follow global trends, condensing four-year degrees into three years. The recommendation carries with it a host of problems, such as a heavier workload for students.

Transitioning from high school to university can be difficult and making the change even more sharp could set students up for failure.

Reducing a four-year degree to three shrinks the amount of education that a student gets, hindering their ability to develop critical thinking and analytical skills.

University isn’t just about getting a degree, and there’s a significant amount of learning that happens outside the classroom in extracurricular activities.

Cutting down the length of an undergraduate degree also cuts down the potential for out-of-class experiences.

Allowing students to graduate earlier will fast-track them into the workforce but it doesn’t do anything to help their employment potential. It would simply be pushing them into an uncertain labour market at a faster rate.

Changing degree lengths is a significant undertaking and requires substantial changes to the curricula at each institution. A study released on Feb. 21 by the Higher Edcuation Strategy Associates, an arm’s length provincial research and advisory group, stated that a three-year degree may not even reduce costs. Redesigning and condensing programs carries a price tag that may cancel out the benefit of not paying for a fourth year.

The Ministry’s other suggestions are also problematic. Having year-round class is detrimental to students who use the summer months for full-time employment. Losing four months to work could be a hard hit on student budgets.

Having half of a degree’s credits earned online would be a loss for quality of education. Participating in a class online simply isn’t an adequate substitute for time spent in a classroom with a professor. The changes proposed for post-secondary education have a number of difficulties associated with them. Students don’t want to rush through their undergraduate degrees — ask a fifth-year.

All final editorial decisions are made by the Editor(s)-in-Chief and/or the Managing Editor. Authors should not be contacted, targeted, or harassed under any circumstances. If you have any grievances with this article, please direct your comments to journal_editors@ams.queensu.ca.

When commenting, be considerate and respectful of writers and fellow commenters. Try to stay on topic. Spam and comments that are hateful or discriminatory will be deleted. Our full commenting policy can be read here.